Sample Report

This is a sample. The store in it is made up, so no real business is exposed. The checks, the structure and the level of detail are what you get. A real report also has screenshots for each finding.

Store: Ceramics Example, a fictional shop at ceramics.example. It sells ceramic tableware and kitchen goods to the US and the EU: about 180 products in 14 collections, some made by small studios and some bought from a wholesaler. It has been on Shopify for two years, on an older free theme, with 9 apps. Audit date: October 2026.

Jump to: Summary | The 10 fixes | All 38 results | 30-day plan | Outside SEO | Limits

Summary

  1. Google can reach the store, but 6 collections, including Mugs, are hidden from search by a leftover noindex tag from an app you removed.
  2. Almost all search clicks come from people typing the store’s name. Collections are named for the shop (“New in”, “Studio picks”), not for what buyers type (“dinner plates”, “pasta bowls”).
  3. 112 products use the wholesaler’s text word for word, and Google has left 64 of them out of its index.
  4. The three things that matter most right now: remove the leftover noindex tag (fix 1), add collections for what buyers search (fix 2), and rewrite your 20 best-selling wholesale products (fix 3).
  5. The whole top 10 is about 19 hours of work. Six of the fixes are quick, about 3 hours together, so start there.

The 10 fixes, in order

Anything that stops Google from indexing a page comes first. After that, fixes are ranked by impact, then by effort. Effort: low is under an hour, medium is 1 to 4 hours, high is more than that.

  1. Remove the leftover noindex from 6 collections (high impact, low effort, 45 minutes)
  2. Add collections for what buyers search (high impact, medium effort, 4 hours)
  3. Rewrite the wholesaler text on your 20 best sellers (high impact, high effort, 7 hours)
  4. Give the homepage a real title and description (medium impact, low effort, 10 minutes)
  5. Fix EU shipping for 37 products in Merchant Center (medium impact, low effort, 45 minutes)
  6. Lighten the mobile homepage (medium impact, low effort, 45 minutes)
  7. Merge the product markup and set real brands (medium impact, medium effort, 2 hours)
  8. Add the product facts AI assistants look for (medium impact, medium effort, 3 hours)
  9. Link products by their main URL (low impact, low effort, 30 minutes)
  10. Redirect the 9 deleted products that still have links (low impact, low effort, 20 minutes)

1. Remove the leftover noindex from 6 collections

Impact: high. Effort: low. Time: about 45 minutes.

  • What is wrong: Six collections tell Google not to index them: Mugs, Bowls, Serving, Vases, Gift ideas and Sale. Mugs is your second-best-selling collection.
  • Evidence: The page source of ceramics.example/collections/mugs contains <meta name="robots" content="noindex">. Search Console lists all six under “Excluded by ‘noindex’ tag”. The tag comes from a snippet that an SEO app left in theme.liquid when you uninstalled it in March. It still reads old “hide” settings the app saved on these collections.
  • Why it matters: A page that Google can’t index can’t rank. These are the pages where people searching for “ceramic mugs” or “serving bowls” should land.
  • How to fix: In Online Store > Themes > Edit code, open the snippet first. Leftover SEO snippets often print the page title and canonical tag too, so check that theme.liquid still prints its own before you remove anything. Then delete the line {% render 'seo-meta-tags' %} from theme.liquid, delete the snippet file, and clear the app’s old settings on the six collections. View each collection’s source to confirm the tag is gone, and use URL Inspection > Request indexing in Search Console for all six.

2. Add collections for what buyers search

Impact: high. Effort: medium. Time: about 4 hours.

  • What is wrong: Your main collections are named for the shop, not for searches: “New in”, “Studio picks”, “The everyday edit”. Plates are a third of your catalog, but they sit inside “The everyday edit”, with no collection of their own. 11 of your 14 collections have no description.
  • Evidence: Search Console, last 3 months: 91% of clicks are for your store’s name. Searches that already show your store but have no page that fits them: “ceramic dinner plates” (2,900 impressions), “pasta bowls” (1,200) and “stoneware serving platters” (800).
  • Why it matters: Collection pages are the pages that rank for buying searches. Without one that matches, Google has nothing of yours to show.
  • How to fix: Create three collections for those searches: Dinner plates, Pasta bowls and Serving platters. Write a page title, a meta description and a short intro (60 to 120 words) that helps someone choose, for these three and for your two biggest existing collections, Mugs and Bowls. Keep the URLs of existing collections as they are, so the indexing you requested in fix 1 isn’t wasted. Keep “New in” and “Studio picks” for shoppers; they don’t need to rank.

3. Rewrite the wholesaler text on your 20 best sellers

Impact: high. Effort: high. Time: about 7 hours, roughly 20 minutes per product.

  • What is wrong: 112 products use the wholesaler’s description word for word.
  • Evidence: Searching one sentence from the Classic Stoneware Mug in quotes returns 34 other sites. Search Console shows 64 of these 112 products as “Crawled – currently not indexed”.
  • Why it matters: When the same text exists on dozens of sites, Google has little reason to index yours. Rewriting all 112 would take weeks, so start where the money is.
  • How to fix: Take the 20 best sellers by revenue among these 112 products. Rewrite each description with what a buyer needs: size and capacity, weight, glaze and finish, dishwasher and microwave safety, care, and what it pairs with. Your reviews already answer half of these questions, so use them. Add alt text to each product’s images while you’re there.

4. Give the homepage a real title and description

Impact: medium. Effort: low. Time: about 10 minutes.

  • What is wrong: The homepage title is “Home”, and there is no meta description.
  • Evidence: The homepage source shows <title>Home</title>. In Google, the result reads “Home”, with a snippet taken from the footer.
  • Why it matters: Your homepage gets most of your brand searches. A clear title and description make those clicks more likely, and tell Google what the store sells.
  • How to fix: In Online Store > Preferences, set a title such as “Stoneware Mugs, Plates and Bowls | Ceramics Example” (under 60 characters) and a one-sentence description of what you sell and who makes it.

5. Fix EU shipping for 37 products in Merchant Center

Impact: medium. Effort: low. Time: about 45 minutes.

  • What is wrong: 37 large pieces, such as platters and serving sets, are limited in Germany and France. They’re in a custom shipping profile in Shopify, and only the General shipping profile syncs to Merchant Center, so Google has no EU rate for them.
  • Evidence: Merchant Center lists the 37 products with “Missing shipping information” for Germany and France. All 37 are in the “Large items” shipping profile in Shopify.
  • Why it matters: Free listings bring free traffic from Google Shopping, and you already ship these pieces to both countries.
  • How to fix: In Merchant Center, give these 37 products a shipping label and add a shipping service for Germany and France that applies to that label, with the same rates as your Shopify profile. Check the products again a few days later.

6. Lighten the mobile homepage

Impact: medium. Effort: low. Time: about 45 minutes.

  • What is wrong: On phones, the main content takes 3.4 seconds to appear for real visitors. Google’s threshold for “good” is 2.5 seconds or less.
  • Evidence: PageSpeed Insights, real-user data at the 75th percentile: LCP 3.4 s. INP (160 ms) and CLS (0.04) are fine. The hero image is 1.8 MB, and a popup app you removed in May still loads about 140 KB of script on every page.
  • Why it matters: Slow pages lose visitors before they see a product, and Google’s ranking systems take Core Web Vitals into account.
  • How to fix: Replace the hero image with a version under 250 KB; 2,000 pixels wide is enough. Remove the popup app’s leftover script tag from theme.liquid. Check PageSpeed Insights again after 28 days, when the real-user data has caught up.

7. Merge the product markup and set real brands

Impact: medium. Effort: medium. Time: about 2 hours.

  • What is wrong: Each product page has two blocks of Product structured data. The theme’s has the price and stock; the review app’s has only the star rating. Both list “Ceramics Example” as the brand, because Vendor is set to the store’s name on every product.
  • Evidence: Rich Results Test on ceramics.example/products/classic-stoneware-mug finds 2 Product items: one with an offer (price and availability), the other with the rating.
  • Why it matters: Split markup can stop Google from showing price, stock and review stars together in search results, and the brand field tells Google nothing about who made the piece.
  • How to fix: Keep the theme’s block and add the rating to it from the standard review fields the app fills in (reviews.rating and reviews.rating_count), then switch off the app’s own markup. In the bulk editor, set Vendor to the studio’s name for studio pieces and the brand on the box for wholesale items, and add the barcodes printed on the wholesale boxes. Studio pieces have no barcode, and Google accepts that for handmade goods: in Merchant Center, mark them as having no product identifier instead of inventing one.

8. Add the product facts AI assistants look for

Impact: medium. Effort: medium. Time: about 3 hours for the top 40 products.

  • What is wrong: Agentic storefronts are on for this store (Sales channels > Agentic), so Shopify shares your product data with AI assistants such as ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot. But your products have no structured fields for what people ask about: capacity, dimensions, dishwasher safe, microwave safe.
  • Evidence: None of your top 40 products has capacity or care information in a product field. Nine mention it inside the description text only.
  • Why it matters: When someone asks an assistant for “a large dishwasher-safe mug”, it’s more likely to recommend products whose data says so clearly.
  • How to fix: For each of your top 40 products, set the right product category and fill in the attributes Shopify suggests for it. Add custom metafields only for facts those attributes don’t cover, such as capacity (Settings > Metafields and metaobjects), and show them on the product page.

9. Link products by their main URL

Impact: low. Effort: low. Time: about 30 minutes in the theme code.

  • What is wrong: Product cards link to URLs like /collections/mugs/products/classic-stoneware-mug instead of /products/classic-stoneware-mug.
  • Evidence: A crawl found 1,140 of these collection-style product URLs. Search Console lists them as “Alternate page with proper canonical tag”. The canonical tags are correct, so nothing is penalized.
  • Why it matters: On a store this size, Google has no trouble crawling the extra addresses. The gain is cleaner signals: your internal links point at the page that ranks, not at 1,140 copies of it.
  • How to fix: In snippets/product-card.liquid, change {{ product.url | within: collection }} to {{ product.url }}.

10. Redirect the 9 deleted products that still have links

Impact: low. Effort: low. Time: about 20 minutes.

  • What is wrong: 41 deleted products now return “Page not found”. Nine of them still have links from other websites.
  • Evidence: The crawl and Search Console show the 41 URLs returning 404. Search Console’s Links report shows links from other sites to 9 of them, including two gift guides.
  • Why it matters: Links from other sites are worth keeping. A redirect sends those visitors to a live page instead of an error.
  • How to fix: In Content > Menus > URL redirects, send each of the 9 to the closest live product or collection. Leave the other 32 as 404s; that’s fine.

What I’d leave alone for now

  • The /products/ and /collections/ parts of your URLs. Shopify sets them, and they don’t hurt.
  • The 1,140 pages marked “Alternate page with proper canonical tag”. That’s normal, and the number will shrink after fix 9.
  • The other 92 wholesaler descriptions. Rewrite them after you see how the first 20 do.
  • The lab score of 61 in PageSpeed Insights. Real-user data is what counts, and fix 6 covers it.

All 38 results

12 pass, 26 fail. Most of the fails are small. The ten that matter most are above.

A. Setup and tracking

  • A1. Search Console and sitemap: Pass. Verified as a domain property. The sitemap is submitted and read without errors.
  • A2. Revenue from search: Pass. GA4 is connected through the Google & YouTube app. Organic search brought 6% of revenue in the last 90 days, though see J1.
  • A3. Bing Webmaster Tools: Fail (optional). Not set up. It takes about 10 minutes to import from Search Console, and Bing’s index also feeds some AI search tools.

B. Indexing

  • B1. Key pages can be indexed: Fail. Six collections carry a noindex tag. Fix 1.
  • B2. robots.txt: Pass. Shopify’s default rules, with no custom robots.txt.liquid in the theme.
  • B3. Canonicals and internal links: Fail. The canonical tags are correct, but product cards link to 1,140 collection-style URLs. Fix 9.
  • B4. Filter, tag and search pages: Fail. About 150 tag-filter pages, such as /collections/the-everyday-edit/blue, are indexed. They get little traffic, so this can wait until after the top 10: add a noindex rule for tag pages in the theme.
  • B5. Broken pages and redirects: Fail. 41 deleted products return 404, and 9 of them have links from other sites. No redirect chains. Fix 10.
  • B6. Indexed page count: Fail. Search Console shows 412 indexed pages against about 260 real ones. The extra are mostly tag pages (B4), while 64 real products aren’t indexed (D4).

C. Structure and internal links

  • C1. Collections match how buyers search: Fail. No collections for plates, pasta bowls or serving platters. Fix 2.
  • C2. Depth and breadcrumbs: Fail (minor). Every product is within 3 clicks of the homepage, but the theme has no breadcrumbs.
  • C3. Links to best sellers: Pass. Best sellers are linked from the homepage and from their collections.
  • C4. Blog: Fail (minor). 3 of 40 posts bring 80% of blog traffic. 22 posts are under 150 words and had no clicks in 16 months: merge or remove them later.

D. On-page content

  • D1. Page titles: Fail. The homepage title is “Home” (fix 4). 74 product titles are only the product name, which is worth improving after the top 10.
  • D2. Meta descriptions: Fail. Missing on the homepage and on 11 of 14 collections. Fix 4 covers the homepage and fix 2 the collections that matter most; the rest can wait.
  • D3. One H1 per page: Pass. The homepage, a collection, a product and a page each have exactly one H1.
  • D4. Product descriptions: Fail. 112 products use the wholesaler’s text, and 64 of them aren’t indexed. Fix 3.
  • D5. Collection intros: Fail. 11 of 14 collections have none. Fix 2 covers the ones that matter most.
  • D6. Images: Fail (minor). 61% of product images have no alt text, and file names look like IMG_4410.jpg. Add alt text as you rewrite each product (fix 3).
  • D7. URL handles: Pass. Short and readable.

E. Structured data

  • E1. Product markup is complete: Fail. The brand is the store’s own name, and wholesale items have no barcode. Fix 7.
  • E2. Organization and breadcrumb markup: Fail (minor). Organization markup is present. There’s no breadcrumb markup, because the theme has no breadcrumbs (C2).
  • E3. No duplicate markup: Fail. The theme and the review app each output a Product block. Fix 7.

F. Speed and experience

  • F1. Core Web Vitals on mobile: Fail. LCP 3.4 s; good is 2.5 s or less. INP 160 ms and CLS 0.04 are fine. Fix 6.
  • F2. App scripts: Fail. A popup app you removed still loads about 140 KB of script on every page. Fix 6.
  • F3. Heavy media: Fail. The homepage hero image is 1.8 MB. Fix 6.
  • F4. Popups on mobile: Pass. None since the popup app was removed.

G. Trust and policies

  • G1. Contact and About: Pass. A real address and email, and an About page that names the studios you work with.
  • G2. Shipping and returns: Fail. The shipping page promises 2 to 4 days to the EU, while checkout quotes 7 to 12. See red flag 2.
  • G3. Real reviews: Pass. 1,240 reviews through a review app, shown on product pages.

H. Merchant Center

  • H1. Connected: Pass. Through the Google & YouTube app.
  • H2. Product health: Fail. 37 products are limited in Germany and France because of missing shipping information. Fix 5.

I. AI readiness

  • I1. Product data for AI assistants: Fail. Agentic storefronts are on, but products have no structured capacity, size or care data. Fix 8.
  • I2. Pages that answer real questions: Fail (minor). No FAQ on product pages, though reviews keep asking about sizes. Add one after fix 3.
  • I3. Mentions elsewhere: Pass. The store is mentioned in two gift guides and one Reddit thread. Nothing to fix.

J. Beyond SEO

  • J1. Conversion tracking: Fail. Purchases are counted twice in GA4. Red flag 1.
  • J2. Checkout: Fail. EU shipping costs appear only at the last step. Red flag 2.
  • J3. Mobile product page: Pass. Price, photos and the buy button are clear on small phones.

30-day plan

The plan groups the fixes by when to do them, not by rank, so the quick ones come first.

  • Week 1, about 3 hours: fixes 1, 4, 5, 6, 9 and 10. Then request indexing for the six collections.
  • Week 2, about 6 hours: fix 2 (the new collections) and fix 7 (product markup and brands).
  • Weeks 3 and 4, about 10 hours: fix 3 (20 descriptions) and fix 8 (product facts).
  • Day 30, check: the six collections are indexed, the new Dinner plates and Pasta bowls collections start to get clicks in Search Console, and the number of products marked “Crawled – currently not indexed” starts to fall. Indexing changes show up within weeks; rankings usually take longer.

Outside SEO: 2 red flags

  1. Revenue is counted twice. GA4 records each purchase twice: once from the Google & YouTube app, and once from a custom pixel someone added under Settings > Customer events. Every revenue figure in GA4 is about double the real one. Remove the custom pixel.
  2. EU shipping comes as a surprise. EU buyers see the shipping cost only at the last step of checkout, and the shipping page promises 2 to 4 days when checkout says 7 to 12. Show EU shipping on product pages or in the cart, and correct the shipping page.

There’s no third red flag: the mobile product page works well.

Limits

  • I promise the work, not the algorithm. No one can honestly promise rankings, traffic or sales.
  • Findings are based on the data available on the audit date.
  • Search figures come from Search Console and are rounded. In this sample, every figure is made up.
  • The red flags outside SEO are observations, not a full conversion or tracking audit.

Want this for your store?

The same 38 checks on your store’s data, with the report in 72 hours. At least five fixes worth making, or a full refund.